Facebook or Own Community ( part 1)
The first question that comes to mind is are brands big enough for anybody to move from a user friendly, loved by all Facebook, to a community that is no doubt 'walled' , or the other way to put is .. Would the brands any day be able to create something that is as attractive as Facebook that can ever scale up to 500 Million users? I think while these are valid arguments, the way one needs to look at these is with a different view; no brand owned community would ever be Facebook like or should even think of competing with it, the focus of the two are very different and more and more examples that I read about suggest is that they are ecosystem partners and can co exist without hurting each others' motive.
A Facebook kind of community exists to enable friends to share their likes dislikes, events that occur in their lives etc etc etc...however a Community hosted by company has few things in mind either to promote their products/services ( directly or as in most of the cases indirectly), or to take customer feedback on what they offer, or many other business cases that are popping up now right from the way Starbucks does it to Mayo clinic...end of it meant to be for one reason 'channelize customers insights to better of their offerings'.
Facebook right from the beginning has been for 'Friends' to connect with each other, though on may argue that they have off late tried to offer tools like Facebook connect... they are more as Jeremiah puts it more of colonization attempts. What is undoubtedly great about Facebook is the scale and the ease with which they have good everybody on board right from Boomers to Millennial generation.
Looking beyond, here is what I believe are the prime reasons that should be kept in mind with the evolving trends in Social Media, while making a decision
* Ecosystem challenge: If one is regular on Social Media space, would know that every day there is there is a new Social Media Beast born ... TechCrunch is full of stories about all new promising tools that would one day scale bigger that Facebook, Twitter etc... so if Foursquare is the new promising baby on the block with already 100 Million users... Tumbler has a good story too. The challenge this poses to the brands therefore is , where to invest time and energy( if not money ) and how many identities to create to woo the customers . Ecosystem of free tools is fairly large, where to stop if you start on this route is a challenge.
* Do not confuse your customers: The above ecosystem challenge when looked from a customer's angle pose a very different challenge, while most of the customers are very happy with Facebook as a basic tool to share and consume information with friends. Is that the end, no, companies today are putting up Support Videos, New product Videos, Product Images etc on other sites that are more focused towards these mediums ( Videos YouTube and the Vimeo, Flickr and Picasa web albums) , customers today if they have to get involved on researching a product have to look at various such sites to see Genuine information about the product, and mind you this is besides the fact that they also look at review sites, blogs etc by other customers ...to check their opinion. I see this changing soon, companies would realize that by putting different stuff on different sites is not only difficult to maintain but also confusing for their customers too, consolidation of various tools (Functionalities as understood in current world) would be the next step, come to one place see all reviews, blogs, videos, pictures etc that you want, doubt if any of the current 'Free to use' platforms would be able to deliver this.
* Customer is king not CEO: In the days to come one thing is sure that more and more conversation that happens outside of company network like Facebook and Twitter would provide meaningful inputs for the companies. Companies would by default create systems to monitor such conversations about their products/services; however the fact that cannot be dismissed is that the starting point of these conversations has to be a product or service that needs to be created, while agreeing that customers can be of help when it comes to suggestions around improving these. To deeply engage with customers on conversations that are meaningful companies would soon need to create and own platform that would facilitate this. Companies have to own at the end of it two things a product or service they create and an ecosystem that enables customers to help them improve it
To be continued....


