Investors in the stock market can choose either of two routes - buy stocks on the exchange or purchase Mutual Fund units. Those taking the stock exchange route can trade real time, place online or offline orders, take intraday positions, go long or short and buy/sell as little as one share. Contrast this with investing in an index-based mutual fund - which represents a basket of stocks comprising a particular index, say, the BSE Sensex. The fund house accepts the buy order subject to a stipulated minimum amount. The price is based on the net asset value (NAV) calculated at the end of each trading day. Now combine the best of both - individual stocks and mutual funds, and you have Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), which are basically index-based funds, which can be traded in a stock exchange.
Advantages
> ETFs are similar to stocks:
• Investors have access to real time quotes.
• Trades can be executed online or offline (through a phone call to the broker).
• There are no forms to be filled out on each purchase.
• Limit orders can be placed.
• Minimum order size is one unit.
> Like mutual funds, ETFs enable investors to diversify their portfolio.
> Because of lower expense ratios, costs involved are lower than those of mutual funds.
Disadvantages
> One of the major advantages of ETFs is that they are traded just like stocks, but stock trading involves brokerage fees so does ETF trading. This can significantly reduce the profit of an active ETF trader.
> Liquidity is low due to thin volumes.
> In many ways, ETF SIPs are not convenient for investment.
> Unlike mutual fund investors, ETF holders have to shell out brokerage fees when reinvesting ETF dividends.
A little about how ETFs are faring today.
Global Scenario
Although ETFs were first introduced way back in 1993, investors evinced interest only much later. Now, they are a rage worldwide. Take the case of the United States. 60% of trading volumes on the stock exchanges there come from ETFs. There are 1,300 listed ETFs with Assets Under Management (AUM) of approximately $1 trillion.
A few popular ETFs:
• QQQs (Cubes) based on the Nasdaq-100
• SPDRs (Spiders) based on the S&P 500
• iSHARES based on MSCI Indices
• TRAHK (Tracks) based on the Hang Seng
ETFs in India
Benchmark launched the Nifty BeEs, India's first Exchange Traded Funds, in 2002. The total ETF AUM today, is in the ballpark of Rs. 10,840 crores. Of this, 83% is held by gold ETFs. Not surprising, given that the yellow metal is a good hedge against risks in uncertain times and is absolutely loved by most Indians.
That being said, the ETF concept has not caught on as expected in India. This can be attributed to a few limitations.
• ETF units are purchased through stockbrokers, unlike Mutual Funds, which follow the distribution model. Brokers have no special incentive to sell ETFs and in fact, find it more profitable to promote individual stock investments. Fund houses have to bring home ETF benefits to brokers.
• The composition of ETFs mirrors that of the underlying indices. Frequent changes in index components necessitate portfolio calibration, adding to the cost.
• Investors can get higher returns from funds which hold stocks that outperform the market.
• Due to demand supply dynamics, ETF prices do not always reflect index values. If there is large variation, it could be on account of price rigging. There has been an instance in the past when the Nifty fell 5% but the price of a Nifty-tracking ETF rose 300% in the space of 3 months.
Little wonder then, that the share of ETFs in the Indian Mutual Fund industry is a mere 0.3% compared to 9% in the U.S. Ways have to be found to overcome these challenges and arouse investor interest.
ETFs that track non-index stocks and other asset classes like commodities, precious metals and currencies, provide opportunities to further distribute risk. This, coupled with the inherent advantages of ETFs will surely lead to higher investments in the future. However, there's a long way to go before these funds become the first choice of investors.