Can banks ward off fintech challenge with a startup mentality?
In recent years, the Bank, that grand edifice of solidity and security from days past, has come under threat from sources ranging from regulators to customers to fraudsters to legacy technology. And today, it stands on the threshold of a new challenger - the technology-driven non-banking player, which sadly is getting into the heart of its business. The Fintech firms and the technology heavyweight (such as Apple, Google and Microsoft) are the prime challengers in this category.
Every bank is also a big technology user in its own right. Today, it is almost inconceivable for a conventional bank to operate without digital technology. Hence, it is interesting how technology firms still manage to eat into their pie.
One of the factors that has led to this development is the banks' outlook themselves. Technology has been a representation of enhanced operational efficiency for all banks. But to technology firms, technology is supreme, and is key to their advancements. And this has spurred them onto exploring newer territories.
Where conventional banks view technology as a means to digitize a part of their business, technology players see far greater possibilities. And they are making it happen in a number of ways - from mobile wallets to P2P loans - that offer customers greater convenience, competitive prices, and certainly, a much better experience.
So where do conventional banks go from here?
The banks, no doubt, enjoy a level of customer trust and confidence, which is extremely hard for their new rivals to achieve and that gives them a head start over the others. What they do need to do is to be agile enough to come up to speed with the changes in their environment and respond appropriately and quickly.
For that, they need to develop the right technology solutions, which are superior to that of tech firms, and combine them with their innate strengths - reach, customer base, capital resources etc. This, in my view, is the best way to take the fight to the opposition, and a much more assertive approach than say, acquiring a technology startup or exploiting a legal loophole to block competition.
How can banks, given their current limitations, do this?
One way to is to sandbox such initiatives, completely isolate them from the rest of the bank and incubate them like a startup. This is like setting up a new bank free of limitations, within the old one.
This bank-within-the bank should be off the legacy system and therefore, free to use a completely new technology platform. It should be well funded, and make use of agile and continuous delivery to deliver small solutions, to start with. Each of these banks or services must treat the parent bank as an external entity and connect with it like any other third party would.
And once it takes off, the parent bank can decide whether it should stay independent or be integrated. DBS Bank, for instance, runs Digibank independent of its legacy environment.
The banking sector is not new to technology-led competition. When Citibank launched its large ATM network in India in the 1990s, and its hugely popular Suvidha account, it was expected to give incumbent Indian banks a hard time. But when ICICI Bank and SBI, rolled out their networks, they negated the foreign bank threat with ease.
These are still the early days for the Fintechs and the technology players in financial services. A large number of banks are experimenting with technology and slowly but surely moving up the ladder. For instance, we are already seeing innovative solutions from Indian banks, both in the private and public sectors.
Recently, the National Payments Corporation of India launched a Unified Payments Interface (UPI) to transform mobile payments in the country. Banks that join the platform will be able to deliver payment apps and wallets to pose a stiff challenge to Fintechs, who might need to reinvent their core proposition to stay relevant.
I am, therefore, optimistic that it is just a matter of time before the banks learn to master the tricks of technology and start using it for launching new products and services.