Scientific research and study have deep roots in natural curiosity and a big impact on human development and our interpretation of the universe we live in. Our blogs discuss, debate and opine on what it takes to spread the culture of science and propagate all important research.

« India's Scientific Roots Provide a Vision for the Future | Main | Enabling India to Shine in the World of Science »

Is India Making the Most of its Human Potential in Engineering?

Indian institutions churn out more than 500,000 science and engineering graduates every year. These and related statistics have been touted as signs of strength for the Indian educational system. However, we should pause here to make a distinction between those who are degree holders and others who actually have a complete education and ready for the workforce.   In the course of my travels I have talked to executives of several leading companies (both Indian and MNC) and a common denominator in these conversations is their need for well qualified new graduates because a significant of the fresh graduates have to be (re)trained to make them functional after they are hired.  This leads me to conclude that a large number of the fresh graduates produced every year are just degree holders.
When I visit universities in the country, I am struck by the deficiencies in their infrastructure and facilities. This is compounded by the mediocre quality of teaching quality in these colleges and the fact that the availability of high quality professorial talent is nonexistent.  All of this indicates - not surprisingly - that our academic institutions are in need of an overhaul if India is to achieve the ambitious development goals that it has set for itself.

The testing and admissions processes in colleges have also come under a great deal of scrutiny lately. In theory, these are merit-based, but in practice, they evaluate the ability of the student to take tests (and do well) in order to gain entry into an institution of choice but not his or her ability to learn and flourish once inside.

This approach, of course, is the antithesis of what one sees in several leading colleges in the US, where students are expected to demonstrate skills and aptitude that translate into success within the university setting. The admissions criteria used combine academic excellence with other achievements that are indicative of well-rounded personality development.  The process in the US is not perfect and certainly, the US educational system has had its share of criticism but, at the university level, it does demand more of students than test taking talent.  And during the 4-year process of getting an undergraduate degree more skills are cultivated and developed than the ability to take tests once a semester.

While I can see several reasons why adopting the US system could be difficult, it is not at all clear to me that adapting the US system to serve the needs of the country should be that hard.  We will all be better served if the graduates of Indian institutions were educated and acquired skills beyond just test taking during their 4-year stint at an engineering college.
The US has a significant entrepreneurial drive - in fact, it is well documented that most employment in the US occurs in small and medium enterprises.   The US higher education system has been a significant contributor to the economic development of the country.  This is the result of significant government investment in research and development at universities, policies that enable and encourage the commercialization of IP created at universities, and a culture of entrepreneurism that encourages and rewards taking risks.    In fact, the US has demonstrated an existence proof of how investment in research and development, creation of an excellent educational enterprise, rewarding risk taking can all be combined to create a virtuous cycle of economic development and job creation.  And there is no reason why any country, and especially India, cannot adapt this model to drive its own economy.

The entrepreneurial drive that has taken over India in the last decade is significant in many respects and bodes well for the country.  It is indicative of a belief that an expanding economy creates opportunities for all, regardless of social and economic background, to thrive.  In order to keep the economy expanding, India has to take several actions. However, a significant action is the creation of several great Indian research universities that will play a key role in increasing the momentum of economic development for decades to come.  This will, for example, require investment in research and training of a few thousand highly trained PhD's over the next decade; it will require an open and peer reviewed process for allocating research grants; it will require allowing foreign universities to operate within the country and compete for the research grants; it will require creating an environment where excellence in research in rewarded and so is transitioning the research.   Seeding this process will require hiring several hundred or more highly qualified faculty members who should be recruited from around the world (Singapore's strategy in this regard could be a good starting point!).  In short, removing bureaucratic hurdles and leveling the playing field, and creating a competitive environment for education and research will go far in achieving the goal of technology enabled economic development.

Creation of an excellent research infrastructure will encourage students to pursue research as an attractive and viable career option.  In steering students back to research to build future researchers and professoriate, we have to convince them (and their parents) that a promising and fulfilling career doesn't necessarily have to wind through the by-lanes of software development and IT services because there are exciting topics to be explored in the fields of engineering and sciences.  And the country is making the investments to develop an infrastructure and an education and research system that will provide the opportunity for people to use and deploy their talent and pursue a fulfilling career.

I am encouraged by the attention given to educational reforms, both by the government and private bodies. New universities with an eye on world class standards are springing up everywhere while older ones such as the Indian Institute of Science in Bangalore are institutional gems - established centers of learning that emphasize post-graduate research and boast of a highly qualified faculty. We have to sustain this momentum through public conversations and initiatives that place the issue on center stage. India will then be well on its way to optimizing its intellectual assets in engineering and the sciences and creating sustainable economic development.


Thanks for the information posted by you. . .

Many young graduates who want to pursue research are not able to do so because of insufficient financial aid being provided by the govt. Recent move by the govt. to increase financial aid making it comparable to salaries paid by corporate will attract talent pool towards research.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please key in the two words you see in the box to validate your identity as an authentic user and reduce spam.